Trusted by professional contractors across North America for 20+ years. Request a Quote →

Why I Always Ask "What's Not Included" Before "What's the Price"

Why I Always Ask "What's Not Included" Before "What's the Price"

If you've ever received a tile quote, you know the pattern: the first number looks reasonable, the final invoice doesn't. That gap between the two is where projects die.

Here's my argument, and I'll defend it below: a transparent total price is cheaper than a deceptively low base price—every single time. Not "usually." Every time. Once you've been on the receiving end of enough surprise line items, you stop negotiating on base price altogether, and you start negotiating on what's actually going to arrive on the delivery date.

The Base Price Is a Decoy (And Almost Everyone Falls For It)

When I sit in on material meetings for a rush renovation, the first number a vendor quotes is almost never the number that matters. That's the base price—the tile itself, at the manufacturer's listed rate. It's the number that makes it into the first email because it's the easiest one to compare across three bids. It's also the number that tells you approximately nothing about what you're going to spend.

What the base price doesn't include:

  • Waste factor. Budget 10–15% overage on any tile order, 15–20% on diagonal layouts. If your installer says "we'll order exact," ask them what happens when a tile cracks mid-cut.
  • Freight—especially for oversized plank sizes, and especially when the only warehouse with enough stock is two states away.
  • Installation materials: thin-set, grout, trim, movement joints, subfloor prep.
  • Cutting and pattern-cutting fees, if the vendor bundles fabrication.
  • Sample and re-ship fees if the dye lot doesn't match the sample board.
  • Design or design-review time, sometimes folded in, sometimes piled on at the end.

What I mean is that "Daltile marble look tile at $X per square foot" and "Daltile marble look tile at $X per square foot including freight, 15% overage, and trim" are not the same number. On a typical bathroom they can differ by 30–40%. On a rush, that gap widens fast. Which is the whole problem.

Rush Orders Turn Small Gaps Into Big Ones

In March 2024, a contractor called me at 6:00 a.m. needing roughly 180 square feet of a specific Daltile marble look tile for a model home walkthrough 36 hours later. Standard turnaround on that SKU was seven business days. He had a quote in hand from another vendor: $1,850. The number looked great.

It didn't include freight from the only warehouse that had enough stock—a different state. It didn't include the 18% overage we had to buy so we could match the dye lot across the whole run. It didn't include the $400 rush pull fee the warehouse charged for same-day pickup. By the time it was all in, his "cheap" quote landed at $3,100. And that was one of the cheaper outcomes I've seen on a job of that size.

The vendor who gave him that quote hadn't done anything wrong, technically. The base price was real. The base price was also irrelevant. What the contractor needed was the all-in number before he agreed to the deadline, not after.

The Vendors Who List Everything Cost Less (Yes, Really)

I've now run enough of these projects—call it 200+ rush jobs over eight years—to trust a very specific pattern. The vendor whose first message includes a line-item breakdown is almost always the cheaper option over the life of the project, even when their headline number is 10–15% higher than the "cheapest" bid on the table.

Why? Because you can actually decide. You can see the assumption they made about waste factor, the freight assumption, the trim assumption. You can push back on the ones that don't apply—maybe you don't need inside delivery, maybe your installer supplies their own thin-set, maybe the subfloor was already prepped. But you can only strip those line items out if they were disclosed in the first place.

Here's something vendors won't tell you: the "cheap" bid is often cheap because it silently assumes you'll accept standard dye-lot variation, standard freight, and a shipment that arrives the day of install rather than the day before. Those aren't lies, exactly. They're defaults. And defaults are where budgets go to die.

"But Doesn't Transparent Pricing Cost More Upfront?"

Yes. It does. That's the point.

The transparent quote is higher because it's honest about the scope. The "cheap" quote is lower because it's honest about nothing. Comparing the two without adjusting for scope is the most common mistake I see—it's why so many renovations end up 20–30% over budget, and why good vendors keep losing bids to bad ones because the good ones "quoted too high."

What I tell clients now, and what I'd suggest you adopt: compare total delivered cost, not base price. Ask what's not included before you ask what the price is. It feels backwards. It's the only way to get a number you can actually plan around.

A Short Checklist Before You Accept Any Quote

These are the questions I run through, in order, every time a quote lands in my inbox:

  1. What's the waste factor assumption? If it's under 10%, ask why. On diagonal patterns it should be closer to 15–20%.
  2. What does "freight" actually cover? Curbside, inside delivery, and liftgate are three different prices.
  3. What's excluded from install? Trim, movement joints, and floor prep are the usual suspects.
  4. What happens if the dye lot is off? Who pays for the re-ship, and how long does it take?
  5. What's the real deadline assumption? "Two weeks" is not a date.

That last one matters more than people think. In our busiest season, when three clients needed emergency Daltile laminate flooring deliveries in the same week—the click-lock kind, not the glue-down—the only thing that saved two of them was knowing 48 hours in advance that the shipment wasn't going to make it, so we could pivot to a comparable product before install day. The third client, who found out the morning of, was the one who paid for the overtime crew.

I'll say this plainly: the customer who asks the boring questions wins. Contractors running model home schedules, designers managing a whole-house punch list, even families upgrading a bathroom while the kids are still transitioning out of a toddler floor bed—everyone benefits from the same discipline. It's not glamorous. It just works.

And a small confession from my desk during bid-review weeks: I keep a bowl of fiber gummies next to the keyboard. It's not strategy, it's just blood sugar. But the habit stuck, and so did the lesson that came with it: the cheapest thing in the room is usually the thing that costs you the most later.

One last note on aftercare, because it comes up constantly in handoff emails to homeowners: when someone asks how to clean shower head vinegar buildup, tell them to bag the head with white vinegar for an hour—not to soak the cartridge assembly the same way. Same principle as the quote. Do the boring thing right the first time, or pay for the dramatic version later.

Share this article: WhatsApp Twitter LinkedIn
Warren Hughes
Warren Hughes

Warren Hughes is a building-envelope analyst specializing in windows, exterior doors, siding, cladding, architectural glass, curtain walls, storefronts, anchors, gaskets, and perimeter seals. He applies ASTM E283/E283M, ASTM E330/E330M, and ASTM E331 to their respective air-leakage, structural, and water-penetration evaluations while tracking pressure differential, deflection, leakage rate, drainage, glass make-up, and anchorage. His field-oriented guides help architects, façade contractors, and developers define mock-up tests, interface details, acceptance limits, and remedial priorities before enclosure closeout.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *